Chapter 9
Amelia went into the kitchen to find a knife. She was anxious to see what was inside the box. She deftly cut each length of tape. The tape was different than the tape they used at home and she wondered if Jack had to purchase it somewhere. It was the kind with strings inside of it for added strength and it took her a few seconds to get through it all. Amelia finished and took a deep breath and opened the box.
She smiled when she saw numerous items, wrapped up in brown paper wrapping. Jack sometimes did this with her Christmas gifts, having her open one item at a time before the big reveal at the end. It was endearing and made those gifts special. She couldn't imagine she would feel this way about whatever he had to say. A letter addressed to her sat on top with the number one on it.
She picked the letter up and hurriedly opened it, unfolded it carefully and saw Jack's scratchy, angular, masculine writing. She carried the box and the letter to the couch and sat down and pulled the blanket over herself. Then with a quick prayer she started to read.
My dearest Amelia,
I know what you have seen and I know what you must think of me right now. I don't blame you for that and I apologize for any hurt that I might have caused you. The fact is that I have been a liar and unfaithful to you and our marriage. Not in a physical way ever. I have never been unfaithful to you physically or emotionally. I love you with all of my heart and can't imagine my life without you. Some things have happened that have forced me to come to terms with some past decisions that I have made that I know that you will be shocked by. Frankly, I hope you do not think less of me for them. But I am getting ahead of myself.
I have talked with Meredith briefly and she thought writing to you might be the best way to explain. I hope I will not hurt you more but I guess I have lost any control I might have had in easing this blow when you saw Samantha and I together that day. It seems a long time ago now though it has only been a few days. There are reasons for what you saw and reasons that I didn't tell you the truth right away but none of those reasons seem to be good enough now. I should not have kept these things from you. I should have been truthful and up front with you about it all. This is my time, I guess, to come clean about it all.
Let me start at the beginning, when I was ten years old I saw Samantha for the first time. It was love at first sight. For years I said nothing to her because I was way too shy to even speak to her but as time went on we became friends. She didn't like me in any sort of romantic way but I was in awe of her. We had a lot of classes together and she ran with the popular crowd. Everyone in school had a crush on her. She had beauty that attracted everyone to her and some of them she would date. It was widely circulated even in junior high that she had a reputation with the boys but I knew that she had never been with anyone. After we became friends we would sit up late talking and I found out that she was really nice underneath it all and I fell even further in love.
Years passed and high school came. We stayed friends though she rarely talked to me at school. We'd sometimes meet at a look out up the road from her house. You could watch the sunset from up there. She lived with her dad and didn't like her step-mom at all so she spent a lot of time away from home. My mom was always at work and Carrie didn't make a fuss when I would leave. Something happened the year she turned seventeen and she went to live with a foster family in another part of the city. We became sort of an item around that time. I went to see her, doing whatever I could to help her. It was around that time that she lived with us for a short time. Carrie let her borrow her prom dress and we went to the dance together. I was in heaven. I told her I loved her and had always loved her. She didn't like it when I talked to her about love and would always change the subject.
She went to college the next year and she called Carrie on the phone pretty often to check in. She started dating a guy who was in the military and I didn't hear about her for a few years.
Then one night eight years ago I ran into her when I was home on a break my last semester of college. I was on top of the world, looking at all sorts of good prospects for work and when I saw her I knew it was now or never. We had danced around it for so long and now there she was at the perfect time. She had recently broken up with her on and off again military boyfriend. They'd been engaged when he left for another tour but he cheated on her over there with a female colleague and she told me that she was done with him. She was different, older, more beautiful even than before and I was mad for her. The first night we were back together she kissed me. I was over the moon. It was my chance to be with her and I was going to take it.
I came back home for the summer. I had an internship in my hometown and things were great. Samantha was my girlfriend and then in just a few days, she was my fiancee. Carrie warned me that I was moving too fast but I didn't care. I was young and in love and I wanted her in my life forever. One day I took her into the city to do some shopping and she brought up marriage. She told me that she didn't want to wait. She suggested a trip to Vegas to tie the knot. I couldn't believe she wanted to get married right away but I jumped at the chance. We booked a flight to Vegas and got married that night. I was happier than I can say. I was also blind.
We were together for five days. The first few days were wonderful days for me. We spent all day together and at first I couldn't believe how happy I was. I couldn't believe that such a beautiful woman was my wife. But as the days went on Samantha grew increasingly moody and distant. She tried to smile but I could tell she wasn't happy. She would lash out in little angry outbursts and then lock herself in the bathroom with her phone. I would hear her talking to someone and she would yell at me to go away. I was confused by her behavior and bought her all sorts of presents and other things to help her be happy again. I was naïve and it showed.
The evening of the fifth day I walked out of the bedroom to find a note taped to the front door. All of Samantha's things were gone and the note was short.
Jack -
Rick is back and I'm going back to him. You always loved me more than I deserve. Please forgive me.
Samantha
Amelia set down the letter with tears in her eyes. She had no idea about any of this but her heart went out to Jack. She knew she should be mad that he had not told her of the marriage but she understood in a way. It would be humiliating to be left like that. She wanted Jack with her now as she read it and felt the weight of what her leaving so suddenly might have done to him. She picked up the letter and read on.
My heart was broken and I didn't talk to anyone about it. I went to a lawyer and found a way to annul our marriage. I was lucky that we had been married in Nevada where divorce and annulment laws are quick and I could prove we had not lived together after we married. It was pretty easy to get the marriage annulled but it took longer for my heart to heal. I didn't even tell Carrie about it. I just tried to move on. I went home and packed up my stuff and got the job in Florida. I had no idea where Samantha went and didn't want to find her. I looked at the whole experience as a huge and painful mistake and moved past it. I had a lot of unanswered questions and a lot of pain associated with her leaving. I tried calling her a few times but got Rick on the phone instead telling me to leave her alone. She called back a short while later and apologized again but told me to move on. That is just what I tried to do.
I didn't date much for a year and focused on building my career. Time passed quickly and I felt like I was finally ready to date again. I dated a few girls but mostly when they asked me out. It was that summer that my mother was diagnosed with cancer. It was a dark time for me in those months before she died. Carrie had moved to Florida after she died and heard about the Center in New York. She was insistent that we go to their workshop for our summer vacation that year. She had heard of the program from a friend and thought that it would be good for both of us to go that summer to relax and heal together. I didn't want to go at first but she offered to pay my way and there was no way to say no. You'll never know how glad I was that I that I joined her at Camp Camilla. If I hadn't I would never have met you.
Look in the box for #1. I think you'll remember it well.
Amelia reached into the box for package number one and pulled off the wrapping. The object that fell into her hand made her smile and she remembered the first time she saw Jack. It was funny now that she thought about it. The shiny object sparkled in her hand and she laughed at her memory of their first meeting. It was the broach Jack had found in the lake when he was swimming dropped by some ancient guest or another. The lake was a bit murky and it was easy to see how something so small could be lost.
It was the summer after college and she was home to study for her nursing exam before getting a job. Meredith wanted her to spend some time with her before she got a job and she was happy to take some time with her. She knew it would be a long time before she would be able to take time off once she started working. She worked at the Center in the summertime helping the nursing staff take care of the all the guests. Jack was her first visitor to the clinic that year. She pulled out the letter marked #2 and continued reading.
You'll remember the day I brought this too you from the lake. I know I came to you for a tetanus shot but I had really come because I thought you were lovely. I saw you my first day there at the lake with Meredith and I asked many of the workers what your name was. Carrie encouraged me to find you and I finally had the excuse I needed when I “found” that old broach with my foot in the water.
The truth is that I thought you were lovely and the first time I saw you smile I knew that you were a sincere person. I learned my lesson from my time with Samantha and took things slow. I waited at least a day to kiss you. Do you remember our first kiss under the bridge in the canoe? I think my heart cemented to you right in that moment. There was something about that summer that made every bad thing that had happened with Samantha melt away. I was finally free. Perhaps it is better to be cautious about all of that. I never had to worry about that with you. You guarded your heart well and I could love you with all that I had. It was different than my former relationships because it was real for us both.
I remember all those nights that we walked together that summer. The days were filled with thoughts of my mother and I respected what Meredith taught us about healing but real healing came for me when I met you and could love you with my whole heart again. I had never found a friend like you, been able to talk with you and enjoy your different moods. You were a lovely mystery to unravel.
By the end of our time at the camp I was ready to propose marriage but I knew that you needed more time. So I waited until you came to visit me in Florida on your many job interviews. When you said you needed time to think about it I knew that you were going to say yes. I knew that you needed time. I knew you well and still do. I'm sorry that this is where we are. I want so much to be with you as I am telling you this but I think Meredith is right. You need time to process this and I will give you time.
There is more that I need to say but let that wait until after my next package.
Amelia reached into the box for #2 and pulled the paper off. It was the picture she had imagined in her mind for those days. A picture of the two of them on their wedding day. It was Jack's favorite though she was not sure why. Her expression was silly but they were happy holding each other under the trees.
I love this picture not just because of the day it represents but of the expression that you had on your face that day. I'd never seen you so happy and sparkling. Your eyes fairly dance off the shot and you were luminous. I remember that day and night often especially through all of our hard nights the last few years. Our time together in those first few days of marriage made everything that happened before a mere memory. I forgave Samantha on that day because I knew then what love really was. I had tried everything to make her love me but I also realized that what I felt wasn't real love either.
The kind of love I see every time I see this picture in more deep and enduring than anything I felt for Samantha. It isn't just falling in love. Love like ours is so much more than that and I hope that when I am done telling you all that I have to say that you will still think that I am worthy of yours. No matter what happens I will always love you.
Look at #3
She opened the package marked #3 and saw a Bible. It was marked with Jack's markings. It was the Bible they read together. Her heart hurt a little when she thought of the deception and wondered what was coming next. All of what had come before could be ruined by what came next. She set the Bible down and picked up the third letter.
Shortly after we got married I started reading the Bible again like I had when I was teenager. Back then I felt that I had a good relationship with God and that he was helping me. When I went off to school I lost my way. I still believed but didn't pray, didn't read, didn't look for guidance. I was lost. After we were married I started a relationship with God again. I prayed about us and took you to church. I felt good again and helped by a higher power. It felt good. It took me a few years to build my relationship with God again. He'd never left me but I had left him and it took some time for me to feel worthy of his love and yours.
When our problems with conception started, I saw it as a consequence of my unworthiness. I knew that God gave children to many and the fact that we were having this issue was sad to me. It might seem strange but I took it personally. I saw it as a punishment from God that we could not conceive. After a while I started to feel the guilt of my prior relationship and not disclosing it to you. I knew that I had not done wrong in loving Samantha and that her deception was not my fault but I felt that I should tell you about her. It was around Christmas time that I finally resolved to tell you. Right during that time we found out you were pregnant and I saw it as a sign that I was forgiven. My logic is not sound but I didn't tell you at that time either.
Open #4
The wrapping on box #4 was Christmas wrap and Amelia uncovered a box of her favorite chocolate. She didn't like to indulge in sweets often but Jack always bought her all her favorites for Christmas.
She reached for her favorite chocolate of the bunch and chewed it thoroughly then reached for Letter #4 and opened it to read.
This is where I have more to tell you about Samantha. I hope the chocolates ease the blow just a little bit. I hope that you will understand my reasons even if they seem hard. I really wanted to explain it all at the time. I could never find the right way until now. I'm sorry that this is the way you are finding out.
About six months ago I got a call from Carrie. She asked if we could meet for lunch. When I got to the restaurant she had her laptop open and showed me her Facebook. She had reconnected with Samantha on Facebook and Samantha told her that she needed to get in touch with me. I was hesitant at first. I didn't want to see her. We were finally happy and I didn't want anything to ruin that. She told me it was important.
I agreed to meet her but only if Carrie were there. Carrie told me that I should talk to you about it first but I insisted that we not. I had nothing to say to Samantha but was still curious about what her life had been like since she left me. I guess in some ways I wanted to prove that I had won. It seems a bit silly now but broken relationships sometimes bring out the worst in us all. Don't be mad at Carrie. She wanted me to talk with you.
We met Samantha at the restaurant and right before we saw Samantha I surprised Carrie with the fact that we had been married for a short time. I've never seen Carrie so surprised. She was hurt that I didn't tell her sooner and I explained some of the circumstances. She seemed to understand after that.
When Samantha came she cut to the chase really fast. She said that she wasn't there to reminisce but that she needed something from me. She informed me that it was possible that I had child and that she needed my DNA to test me. She wouldn't say more than that. Carrie was speechless and I was shocked. All I could do was swab my cheek and give it back to her. Samantha asked for my phone number so that she could call me with the results. She left without eating with us and Carrie and I talked about whether or not to tell you.
It was just days after we found out you were pregnant and I was worried that the shock of this news would do something to hurt your chances of keeping the pregnancy so I decided to tell you after I got the test results back. I didn't want to worry you unnecessarily. We had enough to worry about with our own child. The idea that I was already a father hadn't sunk in at all. I thought there was very little chance that I was the father because we were together such a short time. I was more worried about you and the situation we faced in your pregnancy.
Two months went by and everything was looking good. After three months I thought for certain that we were in the clear. The morning of the 14th came around and I got a call from Samantha. She told me that she had them send a copy of the test results in the mail and that it should arrive soon. There had been a back-up at the lab she used and she apologized for the long wait. I asked her if I was the father and she said that she didn't know either. They were sending them to us both. We arranged a time to talk. She apologized again and hung up.
I don't need to tell you how devastating it was when our baby died that next morning. I know they say that it happens often but sitting in that ultrasound room with you when they couldn't find the heartbeat shook me to my core. I watched you go through that process and felt so powerless to help you. You were so brave and strong. After all the time of wishing and praying for the baby and the excitement of those fourteen weeks and then there was no heart beat. It hurt too much to talk about. That afternoon when I went home after your surgery to get your things, I found the letter in the mail with the DNA results. I was the father of Samantha's baby.
I'd like to say that I wanted to run to you with the news but I was so confused as to what to do. There you were still hurting in the hospital and I am talking with my ex-wife about a baby, a little girl that she had never bothered to tell me about. It took me a few weeks to know how to proceed. I was so angry. I was angry that she had never told me I could be a father. I was angry with myself for not telling you sooner about Samantha. I was angry that our baby was gone and my old fear that God had not forgiven me for keeping the truth from you returned with a vengeance. You were so distant there was no way I wanted to approach you with the knowledge I had. I couldn't see you forgiving me for that. I couldn't see talking to you about it at the time. It was all so new and hard for me that I could not see my way through.
Then about a month ago things started to improve between us. You seemed to be moving out of your grief and we started reconnecting again and talking about more children. Things were so delicate that I couldn't say anything. I was a coward and I am truly sorry for that.
Open #5
Amelia pulled out the fifth item which was in an envelope. It was a heart shaped paper made out of construction paper. A child had written on it and Amelia realized that it was Jack's daughter who had made it for him. Amelia unfolded it with a lump in her throat. On it the child had written, To my dad, love Kate.
Amelia stared at it for a few moments and thought of Kate. The little girl did not know her father. Just as she had never known her own. Her heart went out to her.
She picked up the last letter and read on.
This heart is from my daughter, Katherine Elise or Kate as her mom has always called her. She was born on May 19th. She named her after two characters she'd always loved on a some TV shows that she liked when she was younger. She is now seven. Samantha never really explained who her father was. According to Kate, Sam would always have a new story about who her father was and where he was living. She'd make up pretty wild tales from the sounds of it. He was a pirate, he was a mountaineer or a gamekeeper in Africa. The truth was that Samantha always believed that Rick was Kate's father and she didn't want him on the birth certificate or anywhere near them. He had left her when she told him she was pregnant with a girl. He was apparently only interested in being a parent to a boy. She didn't want to return home to her family. Her father was always mean and her stepmom was still in the picture. So she found a friend who she had gone to church with as a girl and moved in with her. She started attending church on a regular basis and had lots of help when Kate came into the world. They still go to the church now though they are living on their own. They have friends there and seem happy.
It took me a few weeks to know what I wanted to do. I know how awful that sounds. I wanted for it not to be happening. With all that has been going on it seemed almost cruel to have to tell you any of it. Then I received the heart card from Kate in the mail along with a short note from Samantha asking if it would be all right for them to visit us some time. I thought about Kate and realized that I wanted to be there for her. I wanted her to know what it was to have a father in her life. We all missed out on having good fathers in our lives and I knew that I had to try to be there for her if I could. I realized that it didn't matter if it was fair or not. It didn't matter what I thought of Sam or anything else. It matters that Kate knows that she has a father and that her father loves her, without any condition. My heart changed toward her and I saw her like a parent sees a child. Kate needs a dad and I felt ready to be the best one I could manage.
Samantha and Kate arrived in town on Sunday night and planned to stay for a week. I thought it would be wise to meet Kate on my own first before I introduced you to her. I was concerned for her that she might not understand who I was. My plan was to meet them at the hotel that day and talk to you that night then invite them over to the house when you were ready, if you were still speaking to me by then. Carrie told me to tell you so many times and threatened my life more than once. She didn't think it was fair to you to keep you in the dark and surprise you but I was worried about us and was cowardly as well.
I know that you must have been shocked by our greeting but it had been a long time since we'd seen each other on friendly terms. Samantha has been having some health issues along with all of this and she told me that she was waiting on some test results. I was concerned for her and hugged her to let her know she'd be all right. She's been my friend a long time and even though she hurt me a great deal when she left I still have that underlying love for her. I want you to know once again that I have no romantic feelings toward her anymore and would never cheat on you. I will apologize for the way I have treated you for the rest of my life if that is what it takes.
I want to talk to you in person now when you are ready. Please take time to think and pray before you come to me. I want to see you and be with you. You are the only woman I want to be with. When you come to me we can talk about it all. But now you know what happened that day and you know how I feel. I can't help but wonder what you are thinking right now.
Loving you is the best part of my life. Please let that mean something as you make your decision.
All my love,
Jack
P.S. Open #6
Amelia let out the breath she was holding and sat thinking and re-reading the last letter. She didn't know what to think or feel about it all, she only wanted to talk to Jack. Her emotions were all over the place. There was anger and hurt and jealousy on the one hand and yet they were far more overpowered by her love and respect for Jack. She loved the man with her whole heart and he loved her back. He had been put in an impossible position and waited to hear what she would say to him.
She pulled out #6 and opened it. Underneath was a scrapbook filled with pictures. Samantha was a skilled scrapbooker and with tears in her eyes Amelia slowly studied the pages of little Kate's life. She was the most beautiful little girl, with Jack's eyes and Samantha's smile. Her hair was also like Jack's, dark and wispy forming tiny curls around her head when she was small and long and straight as she grew up. The most recent page was a picture of Jack with Kate. His arm was around her shoulder and they were smiling for the camera. Amelia's heart ached a little as she stared at their faces. The man that she loved with her whole heart and his little daughter. She knew in that moment what she wanted to do. Under the photo was another envelope entitled, When you are ready, find me.
Amelia was startled by a knock at the door. Meredith popped her head in the door. “You ready for dinner, dear?” When Meredith saw Amelia's face she came in close to hug her. “Oh, honey. Oh, sweetheart.” she exclaimed and Amelia threw her arms out to Meredith and she nestled her in her arms.
“Do you know it all then,” Meredith asked directly. Amelia nodded, “I think so, yes.”
“Are you ready to talk with him?” she asked quietly. Amelia nodded again, “I wish he was here right now. I'd go right to him.”
Meredith smiled, “That's what I wanted to hear. Come along.”
Amelia followed Meredith to the door and she lead her out to a waiting cart with covered dinner trays on it.
“I know how much you love the island and know you've been anxious to get out there so do you think we could eat our meal out there tonight? We could have a picnic and watch the sun go down.” Meredith said happily.
Amelia was confused and a little annoyed. “I want to talk to Jack.”
“Of course, dear. You can talk with him. But I've prepared this special meal and I want to share it with you.” Meredith said forcefully.
“I don't think I'd be very good company tonight. I need to talk to Jack.” Amelia came back.
Meredith used her most demanding expression, “Not until you come out with me. I know where he is and I will not allow it until you've eaten a proper meal.”
Amelia stared at Meredith like she had lost her mind but resigned herself to her fate. “Okay, if it means that much to you.”
Meredith's eyes sparkled, “It does. I think you will really enjoy what I've prepared.”
Amelia helped Meredith secure the food in the boat and they set off across the water.
Amelia was preoccupied with her thoughts and was silent across the water. Meredith chatted loudly about her baby bok choy and curried nut salad. After a few minutes she enjoyed the ride and knowing that she was going to the island was a treat. She only wanted to talk to Jack first. Then she would enjoy herself. She had to talk to him soon. They docked the boat and Amelia helped Meredith carry the trays of food to a small table on the west facing deck.
A movement from the house caught her attention and she gasped when she saw a tall figure moving toward her through the open glass door.
Meredith smiled over at her. “Enjoy!” and she retreated down the path to the boat. Amelia watched in astonishment as the man walked out the door and stood to meet her face to face.
Jack smiled at her tentatively and moved closer to her.
Amelia couldn't help her reaction to seeing his face. Tears sprang into her eyes as she closed the gap between them and wrapped her arms around his waist.
“Jack! Jack!”
He caught her up and held her to him and they were silent for a long time.